Tuesday, 4 March 2014

Lost Hotels - The Golden Rule


The Golden Rule Hotel 


Tuesday, 9 March 1909, was a sad day for many of Adelaide's beer drinkers and hotel patrons. On that day, the Licensing Bench ordered the closure of 37 hotels throughout Adelaide and its surrounding suburbs.

Among those serving on the Bench were Messrs. J. Gordon, S.M., W. Gilbert, W. Burford, W. Kither, T. H. Booker, and W. D. Ponder, M.P. While some of the closures were undoubtedly justified, the decision nevertheless marked a significant change to Adelaide's hotel landscape.

Of 413 licence renewal applications considered across the Port Adelaide, East Torrens, and Sturt districts, a substantial number were refused. Thirty-one applications relating to older hotels were granted, while fifteen clubs obtained new licences. However, twenty-seven applications for wine licences were refused, along with ten applications for the renewal of storekeeping wine licences.

Hotels That Lost Their Licences

  1. Paris Portland (T. Adams)
  2. Sussex Hotel, Port Adelaide (G. Bishop)
  3. Blythwood Hotel, Mitcham (Ellen Blackham)
  4. Kensington Hotel, Kensington (Albert E. Bleechmore)
  5. Australia's Pride Hotel, Port Adelaide (T. J. Blencowe)
  6. Jervois Hotel, Port Adelaide (Honora Brady)
  7. Burnside Hotel, Burnside (Annie E. Canny)
  8. Unley Inn, Unley (J. C. L. Chapple)
  9. Forest Inn, Black Forest (B. J. Conry)
  10. Mafeking Hero Hotel, Hindley Street (P. M. Daly)
  11. World's End Hotel, Magill (J. Dick)
  12. Morphett Arms, Morphettville (J. Foody)
  13. Mountain Hut, Glen Osmond (W. Forrest)
  14. Berkshire Hotel, Glenelg (Emily M. Frearson)
  15. Golden Rule Hotel, Pirie Street (Elizabeth B. Frith)
  16. Rising Sun Hotel, Kensington (W. J. George)
  17. Vine Inn, Glen Osmond (A. M. Gibbons)
  18. Lass o' Gowrie Hotel, Port Adelaide (H. Goddard)
  19. Lady MacDonnell Hotel, South Road (E. Grindell)
  20. Scotch Thistle Hotel, Portland (J. Hutchison)
  21. Prince's Hotel, Port Adelaide (R. Jonas)
  22. Ship Inn, Port Adelaide (J. L. Joyce)
  23. Royal Oak Hotel, Paddington (James Julian)
  24. Thornton Hotel, Glanville (F. J. Martienson)
  25. Kentish Arms, Kent Town (Florence Millar)
  26. Mitcham Hotel, Mitcham (R. J. Miller)
  27. Duke of Wellington Hotel, Port Adelaide (Christina Parker)
  28. Vintage Shades Hotel, Norwood (Alice Ryan)
  29. Family Hotel, Norwood (Matilda Stephenson)
  30. Brighton Inn (H. Harris)
  31. British Standard Hotel, Alberton (E. J. Symonds)
  32. Terminus Hotel, Glenelg (Ellen Thompson)
  33. Paradise Bridge Hotel, Paradise (Anna Waite)
  34. Hawkestone Arms, Mitcham (J. M. Waite)
  35. Kew Hotel, Kew (J. H. West)
  36. Brunswick Pier Hotel, Port Adelaide (Johanna Winslet)
  37. Dock Hotel, Port Adelaide (A. Kluck)

The Golden Rule Hotel

One of the most controversial closures was that of the Golden Rule Hotel in Pirie Street. The hotel's licence renewal was strongly opposed by police, but the most outspoken critic was William Edward Conroy, a timber merchant whose business stood directly opposite the hotel.

Mr Conroy publicly stated:

"The Golden Rule Hotel was absolutely unnecessary to the public. I have patronised all the hotels in the vicinity. I have not inspected the interiors of the other houses, and have not been in the Golden Rule twice in nine years. It was the worst conducted house in the street. I have seen six or seven licensees in the house, and they came and went like chaff before the wind."

Another local resident, Richard Hanley of Pirie Street, voiced a similar opinion:

"I live opposite the Golden Rule, which is the scene of frequent rows. There were only four hotels in Pirie Street from King William Street to Hindmarsh Square. A highly respectable class of people live in the vicinity of the Golden Rule, and I am one of them!"

 

Inspector Davey, who supported the closure, described the hotel as old and undersized, arguing that it was no longer necessary for public accommodation. He acknowledged that improvements had recently been carried out following his request to Mrs Frith in December, although he could not say what the work had cost.

The hotel's licensee, Mrs Elizabeth Frith, had recently been widowed and was running the establishment with the help of her married sister. At the time of the hearing, she had held the licence continuously for two years, contradicting some of the claims regarding frequent changes of management.

Mrs Frith told the Licensing Bench that she had spent considerable money on repairs and improvements to the building. She also argued that there had been no fights in the hotel since she had taken over and that the business was trading profitably through both accommodation and bar patronage.

Supporters of the hotel even organised a petition in an attempt to save the licence. However, the Licensing Bench refused to accept the petition as evidence and declined to consider it. The property was leased to Mrs Frith by the South Australian Brewing Company for 30 shillings per week.

The building that once housed the Golden Rule Hotel stood on the eastern corner of Pirie Street and Moger Lane. Following the loss of its licence in 1909, the property was eventually absorbed into the adjoining Government Garage, which occupied the entire site until relocating to Gilles Street in 1967. And so Adelaide lost another of its drinking establishments, along with a small but fascinating chapter of the city's social history.

Researched and written by Allen Tiller © 2014


No comments:

Post a Comment